Previously on…
Back in what feels like a different life, I covered Season 1 of Shrinking while spending 2 months in a day clinic for depression and burnout. It was exactly what I needed. I have been much better since, and have started to do what anyone with some juicy trauma would: stand-up comedy and writing screenplays.
But as of now, I mainly continue to be a university lecturer and an occasional recapper, so welcome to Season 2 of Shrinking, created by some of my favorite people in and on TV: Bill Lawrence, Brett Goldstein, and Jason Segel.
***
Recap: 2×01 – “Jimmying”
Shrinking is a show about crossing boundaries. If that wasn’t clear after Season 1, the Season 2 premiere hammers that home. The central premise is a therapist crossing boundaries with his patients, seemingly yielding great results with his unconvential methods, until one of them pushes her abusive husband off a cliff. “Jimmying”, as one of Jimmy’s (Jason Segel) patients, Sean (Luke Tennie) calls his method, has its prize – and is also the name of this episode, written by Rachna Fruchbom and directed by Randall Keenan Winston.
Grace (Heidi Gardner), the patient who as it turns out did not kill her husband, but severely injured him, is in jail, a physical boundary separating her from Jimmy, and her former life. Jimmy meanwhile is so haunted by her that he dreams about his mentor Paul (Harrison Ford) pushing him off a cliff. In the nightmare, he tells him: “If my patients don’t wind up okay, I’ll still be fine. You? Not so much.” Paul knows how to set healthy boundaries with his patients, Jimmy doesn’t. He even enlists his best friend Brian (Michael Urie) to take on her case, despite the fact he isn’t a criminal defense attorney. (I called that in a previous recap, people tried to tell me that would’t work, I said it’s TV, here we are). Liz (my spirit animal, Christa Miller) and Derek (Ted McGinley)‘s son has a crush on Alice (Lukita Maxwell), Jimmy’s daughter and has to be told by his parents “how to live near a girl, and not make it weird.” Liz, ever the meddler, keeps interfering with Gaby’s (Jessica Williams) friends with benefits situation (or “roomies with bennies”) with Jimmy, interrupts her lecture (I would murder her!), and even goes to her house to unpack her moving boxes. (Sidenote: I moved last week, can someone do this for me? At least I know where my bath towels are). Gaby meanwhile overshares her personal life with her student (also relatable).
The narrative thread of this half hour however is also the idea of triggers, and regression. Alice is terrified of the idea her father will regress to how he was for months after her mother’s death – the way we found him in the series’ pilot. He has made progress over the course of Season 1, also exemplified by the way he can now actually talk about how Tia died, something he, and thus the show, completely avoided adressing. (It was a car accident, a drunk driver.) He tells Sean when he talks about triggers – they are “everywhere”, he stills thinks about it every time he hears sirens. If you know how good writing works, you knew this would have a pay-off later, and woof, it sure did.
Paul meanwhile pushes his lover Julie (Wendie Malick) away, running away from commitment as he always does – but actually manages to escape regressing to his lone wolf ways fully by telling her he loves her. “It’s not how it works, chief” – either you fully commit and get all the benefits and downsides of a relationship, or you get out.
And yet, Gaby is still sleeping with Jimmy, and even though she knows he isn’t ready for an emotional commitment. It’s the same pattern she had with her ex-husband, as she’s a “pathological caretaker”. Shrinking previously adressed codependency (as did Ted Lasso’s third season, shout out to one of my favorite jokes about CODA), so this is par for the course. Gaby realizes she needs to get out to not regress herself, and Liz was trying to warn her, in her own, obnoxious way.
Jimmy needs to stop being Sean’s therapist for the same reason, and while they are both reluctant at first, he switches to Paul by the end of the episode, so he can actually move on – and reconnect with his old life and friends.
Triggers are everywhere. It’s funny that now that I see the opening credits and hear the title song (“Frightening Fishes” by Tom Howe & Ben Gibbard) I am immediately transported back to the day clinic I spent 9 weeks at. Don’t worry, that part is the good memories. Being confronted with the things that brought me there in the first place? That’s a different story. The episode ends with Jimmy getting a visit from the drunk driver that killed his wife, a clean-shaven (woof) Brett Goldstein, and begins to spiral.
***
Funniest line: “I’m currently wearing a thong from the eighth grade, cause I haven’t had a second to unpack. It’s so unbelievably small, it’s like a hammock for my bush.”
Biggest woof: “I love you.” – “Well, that sucks. (…) I love you too.” – “Shit, I was afraid you’re gonna say that.” Too real.
P.S. I should note I once discussed the whole boundaries theme with my friend and colleague Eric Rauchway over margaritas, fittingly in LA, so if you’re reading this, hat tip to you.
***
I will cover Shrinking Season 2 weekly on Wednesdays for the rest of the year. Find all my Season 1 recaps here. I also previously covered Ted Lasso Season 3, and reviewed Superbob.

