Recap: Shrinking – 3×09 – “Daddy Issues”

Written by Rachna Fruchbom

Directed by Anu Valia

Last week I noted that Gaby was the first character to experience a big setback while trying to move forward… and well, now she’s no longer alone, because it hits Jimmy big time. It made most sense for him to be the one, given he’s still in many ways who the show’s narrative revolves around, even when the supporting characters by now got their own rich lives.

So, let’s start with them first before circling back to him. Sean gets a call from Dre Thibodeaux to let him know he got the job as a sous chef! Which means he has to tell Jorge that the food truck is no more. (But couldn’t he sell it to him…?) So he needs a lesson in being selfish, and who better to do that then resident narcissist, Brian? He gives him and Derek an off-the-cuff TED talk on being selfish, just like Mother Theresa would. Sean takes his one good piece of advice to heart: you need to make yourself happy first to be there for anyone else. Jorge, as expected, doesn’t take the news well. He yells at him, but crucially, Sean stays calm. His PTSD isn’t triggered. Paul is, once again, rightfully proud. And learns how far he has come himself, given he, too, had an asshole of a father.

Gaby is doing better, did accidental Hobbit dick nail art and is taking Derrick with her on hikes, but she’s still not ready to go back to work. So, Paul sends in the big guns: himself. He’s already on his last week of work, and still wants her to take over, so he needs her to soak up all of his wisdom. By the end, he reveals the – somewhat expected –  twist  he wants her turn the practice into a trauma center. He admits he never had the balls for the heavier work, but believes she can do it, given she changed his own life. (“You are my legacy” will not have left many eyes dry.) Leaves only one question: is he actually moving to Connecticut? And if yes, what about Julie?

Now as for Jimmy: he is thinking about Tia – he always is, but maybe even more now that he’s with Sofi. They’re moving fast, Sofi even drops by work unannounced, meeting Paul, who’s happy for them (and takes credit for Jimmy’s progress). But he’s even more preoccupied with his titular Daddy issues because Jeff Daniels is back in town. His Dad is a cool guy everyone likes – unless you know him better or well, were (not) raised by him. He breezes in and out of town, plays guitar and fixes up cars, and all of his memories of Jimmy’s childhood are romanticized or just lies. Just like a Billy Joel concert that should have been a pivotal moment because of the transformative powers of Joel’s music rather than being inadvertently flashed by a 60-year old woman as a 7-year old boy. (This anecdote could have happened to Brett Goldstein or at least been cut from his stand-up, it slots right in). Now is a good moment to remember that we started the show with a high Jimmy playing air piano to “Prelude/Angry Young Man”…

Alice asks Jimmy to help out with fixing up the car her grandpa brought, that also turns out to be his graduation present. Of course, Jimmy already gave her one, which he’d know had he ever been around. And while they manage to make it past that awkward moment, even with Sofi there, it all escalates when he tells Jimmy he will bail right before the actual graduation ceremony to go on a fishing trip (and it’s not even an emergency fishing trip!). He also refuses to tell Alice himself, to avoid any conflict, sticking Jimmy with all the emotional labor. And that’s all after he had once promised to show up for them following Tia’s death. Who  – he casually drops into conversation – he never liked, but Sofi, he likes her, he even thinks she’s a better fit for Jimmy than Tia ever was. Woof. No wonder Jimmy spirals into breaking it off with Sofi, thinking he’s not ready. Which may be true, and Sofi being insecure about Tia surely doesn’t help, but clearly it’s really just triggering a bunch of unresolved shit with his Dad, rather than unprocessed grief over his dead wife. I had suspected last week this may blow up, didn’t expect it to be this quickly – but then again, a lot can happen in those next two episodes…

Funniest line:  “I’m never coming to Connecticut, that place is just white privilege and boat shoes.” – “Don’t mock my culture.”  / Summer’s Ed Sheeran paternity test anecdote, just cause I haven’t given Rachel Stubington her flowers in a while –Summer is so delightfully off-kilter as a character and her delivery is dead on every time.

Biggest woof: “She may even be a better fit” is some brutal, twisted shit. If Jimmy falls off the wagon again after this, I would not be surprised.

P.S. I know it’s cause of the fires but the fact the food truck is now always parked in the middle of the Warner Lot keeps throwing me off. Rooster, the new Bill Lawrence show that just started airing on HBO Max, also partially filmed there (some of those houses they use are around the corner from that set, iirc) – so couldn’t they have had a Phil Dunster cameo? Jorge could have thrown some shrimp at him, too?

P.P.S. I forgot to note last week that we got to hear a song by Brett Goldstein’s bestie and all around awesome artist Mae Martin at the end, it’s called “I Love You So Much”. Check it out here.